Capitalizing on Credit Card Surcharging: A Guide for Businesses

Credit card surcharges are additional fees charged at the point of purchase to cover costs associated with processing credit card payments.  This is usually presented separately to customers on the payment terminal as a small percentage of the total transaction. The specific surcharge amount can vary depending on the size of the transaction and the jurisdiction where the surcharge is levied. 

Surcharging is an option that can be valuable for businesses to help reduce card acceptance costs.  

The Purpose and Benefits of Surcharges

Businesses can choose to implement credit card surcharges to offset costs tied to processing credit card transactions. Anytime a customer pays for products or services with a credit card, the business accepting payment is subject to fees associated with card acceptance.  By passing on a surcharge to their customers, businesses can recover some of these costs instead of absorbing them, which can be a strategy deployed by some businesses to ensure profitability. 

Accepting credit cards also entails other costs, including maintaining the necessary hardware and software, ensuring compliance with security standards to protect cardholder data, and handling chargebacks in the event of fraudulent transactions. 

Navigating Surcharge Regulations

In Canada, regulations regarding credit card surcharges vary by province, with Quebec being the only province that does not permit credit card surcharging.  Credit card networks, such as Visa and Mastercard, have guidelines on surcharges, including limits and notification requirements. Different countries have varying policies on consumer protection and business operations. Businesses operating across multiple provinces or internationally must understand and comply with these regulations to avoid legal complications.

Nationwide, businesses implementing a surcharge must inform customers in advance of the checkout experience that they will be required to pay a surcharge.  The surcharge amount is typically a percentage of the transaction. In Canada, the surcharge amount is capped at a maximum of 2.4%.  

Key Considerations for Implementing Surcharges

Before implementing surcharges, businesses should consider several factors:

• Legal Compliance: Ensure that surcharges are legal in your region, understanding local laws and regulations.
• Credit Card Network Rules: Comply with rules set by credit card networks (e.g., Visa, Mastercard, American Express) regarding surcharge limits and customer notification requirements.
• Customer Transparency: Communicate any additional charges to customers through visible signage, website statements, or verbal notifications during transactions.
• Impact on Customer Behaviour: Evaluate how surcharges might influence customer choices. Some customers might choose alternative payment methods, but some customers may reduce their tip amount (if in a business accepting tips), reduce total spend or even take their business elsewhere. 
• Cost-Benefit Analysis: Assess whether the revenue from surcharges outweighs potential risks based on adjusted consumer behaviour. 
• Market Position and Competition: Understand how competitors handle credit card fees and surcharges.
• Frequency of Credit Card Transactions: High volumes of processed credit card transactions might make surcharges more beneficial. 

Advantages of Credit Card Surcharges

Applying credit card surcharges helps businesses recover fees incurred from processing credit card payments, reducing overhead and potentially keeping product or service prices stable. Additionally, surcharges can incentivize customers to use lower-cost payment methods, such as cash or debit cards.

Selecting the right approach to credit card surcharges should align with a business's commitment to customer service and fit with its operations. The goal is to stay profitable while ensuring fair and convenient transactions for customers.

‍