How Payment Options and Consumer Preferences Impact Online Shopping Behavior

Cart abandonment remains a significant challenge for online retailers, but a recent study by PYMNTS Intelligence and Adobe offers actionable insights. According to the February report, 70% of consumers say that the availability of their preferred payment method plays a crucial role in where they choose to shop online. This suggests that payment options can be a make-or-break factor in the eCommerce world.

‍

Why Payment Options Matter

The report underscores how essential payment options are to the online shopping experience. A staggering 70% of shoppers say they are highly influenced by the payment methods available at checkout. This preference impacts cart abandonment rates, with many customers leaving their carts when they don't see their preferred way to pay.

Online marketplaces seem to outperform brand websites in offering these preferred options. The study shows that 53% of shoppers believe marketplaces, such as Amazon, excel at providing payment choices. In comparison, only 22% felt the same about brand-specific sites. This disparity may explain why brand websites suffer from higher cart abandonment rates—averaging eight abandoned carts in the last 30 days compared to six on retailer sites and seven on marketplaces.

The takeaway for retailers? Expanding payment methods could help reduce cart abandonment and increase sales conversion, particularly for brand websites struggling to keep pace with the marketplaces.

‍

Generational Differences in Cart Abandonment

The report also reveals a notable generational divide in cart abandonment behavior. Millennials are the most likely to abandon their carts, with an average of five abandoned carts in the past month, followed by Gen Z with four. In contrast, baby boomers and seniors abandoned fewer than one cart over the same period.

This suggests that younger consumers may use their carts for price comparisons or as wish lists, while older shoppers are more likely to complete their purchases. Retailers should take these behaviors into account when targeting younger generations, possibly offering strategies like faster checkout or personalized reminders to convert cart abandoners into buyers.

‍

Platform Preferences Based on Product Category

Consumer behavior also varies by product category and shopping platform. For electronics, 48% of shoppers prefer online marketplaces. A similar trend exists for home furnishings, where 37% prefer marketplaces, and clothing and accessories, where 37% favor marketplaces and 36% opt for retailer websites. Interestingly, for groceries, 44% of consumers prefer shopping on retailer websites or apps, showing loyalty to established chains in this category.

These patterns emphasize the need for a multichannel strategy, ensuring that retailers are meeting consumers where they prefer to shop for specific products.

‍

Actionable Takeaways for Retailers

To stay competitive in the rapidly evolving online shopping landscape, retailers can use the following strategies:

1. Expand Payment Options: Offering diverse payment methods can reduce cart abandonment and boost conversions.
2. Address Generational Preferences: Simplifying and streamlining the checkout process could help convert more millennial and Gen Z shoppers.
3. Optimize Platform Strategy: Tailoring strategies to meet customer preferences on different platforms and product categories can help capture more sales.

Incorporating these insights can empower retailers to reduce cart abandonment and drive sustainable growth.

‍